#39 Shock Advertising: How Far Can An Experimental Ad Campaign Afford To Go?
A good ad campaign is one that evokes a widespread response. In the case of one that is experimental in nature and claiming to be educational, how far is too far?
Hello,
Welcome to The Book People, a weekly newsletter on the business of media and storytelling.
In a recent turn of events, a social awareness campaign disguised as the breaking news of a famous Instagram celebrity’s sudden death to cervical cancer tore the internet apart. Upon the announcement, audiences found themselves grappling with the confusion of it all — how did Poonam Pandey die all of a sudden? More importantly, is this really how cervical cancer works?
About a day later, the conversation shifted to a new topic: how far can a marketing campaign go in the name of awareness?
If an awareness initiative blows up online, gets people talking, bags views and extensive readership, it has done its job of grabbing attention. But when an ad campaign embodies qualities that overlap with that of a controversy, audiences are bound to reevaluate the amount of attention they are willing to pay to the campaign.
Eventually, the agency involved in Poonam’s awareness campaign released information, resources, and relevant data on cervical cancer, and addressed the dissatisfaction felt by audiences due to the execution of their idea. The statement released by the agency mentioned that the approach was mindfully crafted to cause a stir and get the ball rolling on the topic. Despite audiences regaining clarity after the controversy unfolded, conversations continue on where the limit lies — for the audiences determining the success of this campaign as well as the campaigners urging them to focus on the message of the campaign.
As of 2023, approximately 2,04,127 women across the globe were diagnosed with cervical cancer, a form of cancer that is curable and preventable if necessary safety measures are taken to prevent it. Quoting a similar statistic along with a plethora of resources relevant to this phenomenon, the initiators of the campaign justified the lengths to which they took their campaign forward.
As we witness the controversy die down and move on to the next, it is safe to say that the audience continually attempts to ponder how can one die of cervical cancer, eager to understand the disease independently.
On the flip side, the takeaway for many was that it was yet another media stunt, designed for its shock and awe value, that inadvertently ended up dampening people's trust in such initiatives.
Barring the chaos that ensued online, the grey area lies in the undeniable impact of this campaign — ironically, through the criticism it received for crossing the limit. By adopting shock advertising as a way to provoke the audiences, the ad campaign may not have been applauded, but it succeeded in surmounting the information overload that social media feeds to its users. Even while it bore a resemblance to a premeditated controversy, Poonam Pandey’s campaign caused the stir it anticipated, and accepted the impact with a pinch of salt.
This leaves us to ponder whether pushing the limits is the answer to producing successful campaigns, or if there is room to achieve the same goal but within the confines of what the audiences define as acceptable.
Job Board
Discover the best opportunities in India’s publishing and creative industries.
Developmental Editor - HarperCollins Publishers India - Gurugram based
Candidates must have 4 years and above experience in ELT (English Language Teaching) school textbooks, masters in English or Comparative Literature, or higher.
Responsibilities include developing English school textbooks for the Indian market including CBSE, ICSE and State boards. The work would include seeing a project through from planning to handover to press.
Interested candidates can apply through HarperCollins Publishers India’s LinkedIn page.
Editorial Coordinator - Oswal Publishers - Agra-based
Candidates must have a Postgraduate degree with English/ Chemistry/ Social Science background, only 0-4 years of experience, freshers are also welcome.
Responsibilities include working in editorial content, blogs, press releases, marketing collateral, and internal communications among others.
Interested candidates can apply through Oswal Publishers’ LinkedIn page.
Weekly Learning
Deepen your knowledge and develop your skills with a new resource every week.
The Right to Write: An Invitation and Initiation Into the Writing Life by Julia Cameron
With the techniques and anecdotes in The Right to Write, readers learn to make writing a natural, intensely personal part of life. Cameron's instruction and examples include the details of the writing processes she uses to create her own bestselling books.
Found this useful? Subscribe for weekly updates and share this newsletter with your friends.
If you have any writing-related questions for the Bound editors, comment below, or reply back to this email!